Armenian Issue Presents A Dilemma For U.S. Jews

LEXINGTON, Mass., Oct. 17 — On the docket for the weekly selectmens meeting here on Monday were the location of park benches, a liquor license for Vinny Ts restaurant and, not for the first time, the killing of 1.5 million Armenians in Turkey 90 years ago.

Members of No Place for Hate in Lexington, Mass., on Monday, when the town cut ties with the Anti-Defamation League, the program’s sponsor, over the killing of Armenians in Turkey.

Raised in Turkey, Hovannes Minasian, center, was among many Armenians attending the town meeting in Lexington.

The debate in this affluent Boston suburb, home to many Jews and Armenians, centered on a local program to increase awareness of bias. The issue was not the program itself, but its sponsor, the Anti-Defamation League, the Jewish advocacy group, which has taken a stand against a proposed Congressional resolution condemning the Armenians deaths as genocide.

If you deny one genocide, said Dr. Jack Nusan Porter, a child of Holocaust survivors and a genocide studies scholar who attended the meeting, you deny all genocides.

The Congressional resolution has created an international furor and deeply offended the Turkish government, both a key ally of Israels and a crucial logistics player for the American presence in Iraq. But as events in Boston suburbs in recent months have shown, it has also put American Jews in an anguished dilemma as they try to reconcile their support of Israel with their commitment to fighting genocide. In the end, the Board of Selectmen here voted unanimously to cut ties with the Anti-Defamation League, as did three other Boston suburbs this week. Three other towns had already done so, with more considering the option.

For many Jews, the issue has involved much soul-searching.

Its hard to talk about it because there are two things or more in conflict here, said Rabbi David Lerner of Temple Emunah in Lexington. Israel is in a very vulnerable position in the world, and Turkey is its only friend in the Middle East. Genocide is a burning issue for us, now and in the past. Its something of who we are.

The House resolution condemning the killings of Armenians as genocide is nonbinding and largely symbolic, but Turkeys reaction has been swift and furious. It has recalled its ambassador from Washington and threatened to withdraw critical logistical support for the Iraq war.

For Patrick Mehr, a Lexington resident who spoke at the meeting Monday, the overriding priority is condemning the killings, regardless of Turkeys response.

The next day at his home, Mr. Mehr, the son of a Holocaust survivor, voiced the anger many Jews and Armenians feel toward Abraham H. Foxman, the Anti-Defamation Leagues national director. Abe Foxman, like George W. Bush, is mumbling that it may not have been genocide, Mr. Mehr said. Foxman talks about commissions of scholars who should study this. That, to me, rang exactly like Ahmadinejad saying, Lets have a committee to study the Holocaust. Give me a break.

Jewish leaders have long sought to focus attention on the killings of Armenians, starting with the American ambassador to Turkey in 1915, Henry Morgenthau Sr., who wrote in a cable that the Turkish violence against Armenians was an effort to exterminate the race. Several members of the House Foreign Affairs Committee who voted for the resolution, including a key sponsor, Representative Adam B. Schiff, Democrat of California, are Jewish.

Several major Jewish groups, like the American Jewish Committee, oppose the resolution, arguing that it is not the best way to persuade the Turks to examine their past.

Mr. Foxman argues that Turkey is the only friend Israel has in the Muslim world, and it has been hospitable to Jews since giving them refuge after they were driven from Europe during the Inquisition.

Israels relationship with Turkey is the second most important, after its relationship with the United States, Mr. Foxman said. All this in a world that isolates Israel, and all this cant simply be waved away.

Widespread attention to the Anti-Defamation Leagues opposition to the resolution came in July, when David Boyajian, an Armenian-American resident of Newton, Mass., wrote to a local newspaper saying that the towns anti-bigotry program, known as No Place for Hate, was tarnished because of its sponsorship by the Anti-Defamation League.

He wrote that the A.D.L. has made the Holocaust and its denial key pieces of the program, while at the same time hypocritically working with Turkey to oppose recognition of the Armenian genocide of 1915-23.

The news shocked most local Jews, many of whom have long been active in campaigns against killings in Bosnia, Rwanda and, most recently, Sudan. By mid-August, Watertown, Mass., had decided to end its affiliation with the Anti-Defamation Leagues program. On Aug. 17, the board of the New England Anti-Defamation League passed a resolution calling for the national organization to recognize the Armenian genocide. Its regional director, Andrew Tarsy, was fired by the national group the next day.

The clampdown on the local chapter infuriated many Jews in the Boston area. Two members of the New England board resigned, although one has since returned, and many local leaders criticized Mr. Foxman. Newton, whose population is heavily Jewish, voted to sever ties with the Anti-Defamation League unless it changed its position on the resolution.

Tag Cloud

External Information

Additional Information

Where Am I?